When managing the affairs of someone who cannot do so themselves, whether due to age, disability, or other factors, two important roles often come into play: the trustee and the guardian. While these roles are similar in some ways, they are distinct legal concepts with different responsibilities and powers.

One common question is whether the same person can serve as both a trustee and a guardian. Let’s explore the answer to that question and provide guidance on these important legal roles. If you need advice on your specific situation, never wait to consult a probate lawyer.

Need Legal Help? Let’s talk

What is a Trustee?

First, let’s define a trustee. A trustee is a person or entity appointed to manage a trust. In this legal arrangement, one party (the trustor) transfers assets to another party (the trustee) to hold and manage for the benefit of a third party (the beneficiary).

The trustee has a fiduciary duty to manage the trust assets in the beneficiary’s best interests and by the trust document’s terms.

Some common types of trusts include:

• Revocable living trusts, which are created during the trustor’s lifetime and can be modified or revoked by the trustor at any time
• Irrevocable trusts, which one cannot modify or revoke once created
• Testamentary trusts, which are created through a will and go into effect upon the trustor’s death
• Special needs trusts provide for the needs of beneficiaries with disabilities without jeopardizing their eligibility for government benefits.

The trustee is responsible for a wide range of tasks, including:

• Managing and investing the trust assets
• Distributing trust income and principal to the beneficiaries by the terms of the trust
• Keeping accurate records of all trust transactions
• Filing tax returns and paying any necessary taxes on behalf of the trust
• Communicating with the beneficiaries and providing them with regular updates on the status of the trust

Trustees are typically chosen based on their experience managing financial assets, familiarity with the beneficiaries and their needs, and ability to act impartially and objectively.

Sometimes, the trustor may choose a professional trustee, such as a bank or trust company, to manage the trust. An estate planning or probate attorney can provide advice on choosing the right trustee.

What Is a Guardian?

On the other hand, a court appoints a guardian to make decisions for someone who cannot make those decisions themselves, either due to age (in the case of a minor child) or incapacity (in the case of an adult who is mentally incapacitated or whio physically cannot manage their affairs). The guardian decides the ward’s personal care, medical treatment, and financial affairs.

There are two main types of guardianship:

• Guardianship of the person, which gives the guardian the authority to make decisions related to the ward’s personal care and medical treatment
• Guardianship of the estate, which gives the guardian the authority to manage the ward’s financial affairs

In some cases, the same person may serve as both the guardian of the person and the guardian of the estate, while in other cases, different people may fill each role.

The guardian’s responsibilities may include:

• Making decisions about the ward’s living arrangements and daily care
• Consenting to medical treatment on behalf of the ward
• Managing the ward’s financial affairs, including paying bills and making investment decisions
• Ensuring the ward’s needs are met and protecting them from harm or exploitation.

Guardians are typically chosen based on their relationship to the ward, ability to make decisions in their best interests, and willingness to take on the role’s responsibilities.

The court may appoint a professional guardian, such as a social worker or attorney, to serve in this role. A probate lawyer can represent family members during the guardianship process.

However, there are also some potential drawbacks to having the same person serve as trustee and guardian.

For example:

• The roles of trustee and guardian require different skills and experience. A person well-suited to serve as a trustee may not necessarily be the best choice to serve as a guardian, and vice versa.
• Serving in both roles can be time-consuming and emotionally demanding, particularly if the trustee/guardian is also a family member or close friend of the beneficiary/ward. This can lead to burnout and potential conflicts of interest.
• If the trustee/guardian cannot effectively fulfill their duties in both roles, this can lead to neglect or mismanagement of the trust assets or the ward’s care.

Ultimately, the decision of whether to appoint the same person as both trustee and guardian will depend on the specific circumstances of the case and the needs and wishes of the beneficiary/ward and their family.

How to Choose a Trustee or Guardian

If you are creating a trust or establishing guardianship, choose the right person to serve in these important roles.

Here are some factors to consider:

• Trustworthiness: The trustee or guardian should be someone you trust implicitly to act in the best interests of the beneficiary/ward and to carry out their duties with honesty and integrity.
• Availability: The trustee or guardian should be willing to devote the necessary time and attention to their duties and be easily accessible to the beneficiary/ward and their family.
• Objectivity: The trustee or guardian can make decisions objectively and impartially without being swayed by personal biases or conflicts of interest.
• Compatibility: The trustee or guardian should be compatible with the beneficiary/ward and their family and can communicate and collaborate effectively with all parties involved.

It’s also a good idea to name a successor trustee or guardian in case the original appointee is unable or unwilling to serve in that role. This can help ensure continuity and minimize disruptions in the event of a change in circumstances.

The Role of a Probate Attorney

An probate lawyer who knows estate planning and guardianship law can assist you with many things, including:

Understand Different Types of Trusts and Guardianships

One key role of an attorney in the context of trusts and guardianships is to help clients understand the options available and determine the best-suited option to their unique situation. There are many types of trusts and guardianships, each with rules, requirements, and implications.

For example, there are revocable and irrevocable trusts, living trusts, testamentary trusts, special needs trusts, and more. Each type of trust serves a different purpose and has advantages and disadvantages.

An attorney can help explain the differences between these types of trusts and guide clients in choosing the one that best meets their needs and goals.

Similarly, when it comes to guardianships, there are guardianships of the person and guardianships of the estate, as well as temporary and permanent guardianships.

An attorney can help clients understand the different levels of authority and responsibility associated with each type of guardianship and determine which is appropriate for their situation.

In addition to explaining the options available, an attorney can help clients understand the legal requirements and procedures for creating a trust or establishing a guardianship. This can include explaining the role of the court, the necessary documentation and filings, and the trustee’s or guardian’s ongoing responsibilities.

Drafting Legally Valid Documents

Another key role of an attorney in the context of trusts and guardianships is to draft legally valid documents that clearly outline the trustee’s or guardian’s powers and responsibilities. This is a key step in ensuring that the trust or guardianship is enforceable and that the beneficiary’s or ward’s interests are protected.

When drafting trust documents, an attorney will typically include provisions that specify:

• The trust defines its purpose and specifies the assets it includes
• The powers and duties of the trustee, including any restrictions or limitations on their authority
• The rights of the beneficiaries and the process for distributing trust assets
• The process for appointing successor trustees and modifying or terminating the trust

Similarly, when drafting guardianship petitions, an attorney will typically include provisions that specify:

• The guardianship application specifies the reason for the guardianship and the powers sought
• The qualifications and suitability of the proposed guardian
• The rights and preferences of the ward, if known
• The process for monitoring the guardian’s performance and modifying or terminating the guardianship if necessary

Drafting these documents requires a deep understanding of the relevant laws and regulations, attention to detail, and the ability to anticipate potential issues or challenges that may arise.

An experienced attorney can help ensure these documents are legally sound and provide a clear roadmap for the trustee or guardian.

Advising on the Pros and Cons of Appointing the Same Person as Trustee and Guardian

As discussed earlier, it may be appropriate or desirable to appoint the same person to serve as both trustee and guardian in some cases. However, one should not make this decision lightly, as it involves potential benefits and drawbacks.

An attorney can help clients weigh the pros and cons of appointing the same person to both roles based on the case’s specific circumstances.

Some potential advantages may include:

• Streamlining decision-making and minimizing potential conflicts between the trustee and guardian
• Ensuring that the trustee has a deep understanding of the beneficiary’s needs and preferences
• Reducing the overall cost and complexity of administering the trust and guardianship

However, there are also potential disadvantages to consider, such as:

• The potential for conflicts of interest or competing priorities between the two roles
• The increased workload and responsibility placed on the individual serving in both roles
• The potential for the individual to become overwhelmed or burned out, leading to neglect or mismanagement of the trust or guardianship

An attorney can help clients carefully consider these factors and decide whether appointing the same person to both roles is in the beneficiary’s or ward’s best interests.

Representing Clients in Court Proceedings

Establishing or modifying a trust or guardianship may require going to court. This can be an intimidating process, particularly for those unfamiliar with the legal system. An attorney can assist by representing clients in these court proceedings and advocating for their interests.

For example, when establishing a guardianship, an attorney can help:

• Prepare and file the necessary petitions and other documents with the court
• Represent the client at the guardianship hearing and present evidence and arguments in support of the guardianship
• Address any objections or concerns raised by the court or other interested parties
• Ensure that the guardianship order is properly drafted and entered by the court

Similarly, when modifying or terminating a trust or guardianship, an attorney can:

• Prepare and file the necessary petitions and other documents with the court.
• Represent the client at court hearings and present evidence and arguments supporting the modification or termination.
• Negotiate with other interested parties to resolve any disputes or disagreements.
• Ensure that the court’s order is properly drafted and entered.

Having an experienced attorney by your side can help uphold your rights and interests throughout the court process and ensure the outcome serves the beneficiary’s or ward’s best interests.

Contact an Estate Planning and Probate Lawyer

While the same person can serve as both a trustee and a guardian in some cases, carefully consider the specific circumstances and needs of the beneficiary/ward before making this decision.

The roles of trustee and guardian are distinct and require different skills and experience, and serving in both roles can be challenging and time-consuming.

If you are dealing with trusts and guardianships, seek the guidance of an experienced estate planning attorney. A probate attorney can clarify your options and guide your decision-making process.

With the right legal support and careful planning, you can protect the interests of your loved ones and meet their needs, both now and in the future. Contact a qualified estate planning and guardianship attorney today to learn more.